@ Diptarka – well done. Great approach and articulation. Missing part – few statistics to support your views + 3

@ aashanaa – Superb ! U nailed it. + 6

@ others – please observe this approach.

@parul approach is good and well constructed. The use of statistics is missing.

Overall quite good + 2

@ Diptarka – I liked the approach which has been followed by you. Concise and well constructed. However focus should be on social network not the band. +5 for approach – 1 fr missing social network

parul singla wrote:
but in cd sir , the one who starts the discussion has to brief about case or not?

Yes, but has to bring his/her own insights and open the case for discussion

Rita has very less documentation available than what is required. Working with what she has – there seem’s to be a trend of price falling sharply whereas increase in price taking place slowly. Considering that she should look at various ratios that the company has in comparison to the industry. For ex: the price to cashflow ratio. By doing so, she…Read More

Sarang Modi wrote:
Typically , Rita needs to look into the market at this point of time,whether the market is favourable for an oil refining company or not. She should also check how the previous oil refining IPOs have fared. She should also check how the other parts of the business are faring and after preparing a detailed report give a green…

Read More

Skill it wrote:
1.Sir, I have absolutely no idea either about crude oil market nor I could comprehend the graph… How should I try to add points or get ideas…morover panick is added weight to it..

You need to be able to analyse data. My suggestion do analyse few graphs. Its not different from data interpretation in CAT exam. Regarding market, you…Read More

Quite good. Missing part is how much funds you need. +2.5 for overall approach