Pritam Mukherjee wrote:
It would be very harsh to comment that investing in gold is a waste of money.

Several valid points. Good start +5 :good:

No mention of Current Account Deficit :negative:

Siddharth Jain wrote:
Can you point out the mistakes

1. The breakup of the business is given. You need to use it while discussing.

2. There is not just an ethical dilemma but also a pressure to give a favorable response. You need to address both issues

Siddharth Jain wrote:
She needs more information ie expansion plans , investment , future takeovers . Global market conditions , conditions prevailing in oil sector in india and international market .

Yes, but are you not missing something?

She must find the reasons for the decrease in revenue in exports . She must bot favour the company in…

Read More

Nikhil Bahrani wrote:
@abhirup bhattacharya what is wrong in interpretation that opec revenues are decresing so oil industry is down

Read your earlier response “As OPEC exports are decreasing oil market is not on a rise so it might be a dangerous investment.” – Exports and revenues are not the same.

Arpa Mitra wrote:
The problem here lies in the fact that Rina has already been instructed to prepare a biased report and she is confined to very limited source of information to prepare her report. Before anything else, Rina must make an effort to gather more data such as the sales report of the company, operating margin, net profit of the…

Read More

Nikhil Bahrani wrote:
Main problem is shortage of information.

Problem statement is not framed correctly. This can be devastating as an opening remark as others are bound to object.

As Rina tandon is working for finterest which is one of leading credit rating agency so she needs to do a thorough analysis as if investment of people who invested…

Read More