At a very conservative estimate, ATM transactions costs banks between Rs 5-10(this includes fixed costs like security/rent/infrastructure and variable cost of transaction processing/cash replenishment). But when the same customer directly swipes his debit card(on which many banks charge a nominal annual fee), the bank earns a commission of around 1%(the balance would go to the bank owning the Point of Sale device), without incurring significant costs. This in a nutshell, is the reason why banks are coming up with ‘free’ debit cards, ad & PR campaigns etc, all aimed at encouraging customers to swipe their debit cards. In a manner that would make any consultant proud, I could dig up the number of transactions/year, apply a random percentage of substitution and come up with a number that could make it to a glossy report or press release for a business magazine/newspaper. 

But this presumes that debit cards will replace ATM transactions/cash withdrawals, and not cannibalize credit card transactions on which banks earn a slightly larger commission, and also interest for delayed payment. In fact, debit card replacing credit card transactions means that banks would lose the CASA(current accounts savings account) float, which is now around 2%-3%(i.e NIM). Therefore, I would expect banks to try mobile marketing/email to specifically target debit card promotions to those customers without credit cards of the same bank. Alternatively, the promotions could be for spends below certain amount so that it competes with ATM withdrawals, instead of cannibalizing the high ticket discretionary spends. But yes, if done right, these promotions could transfer consumer surplus to those banks strong in CASA/debit cards but not in credit cards. To avoid poor decision making like Bank of America’s effort in late 2011 to levy debit card fees(customers saw it as charging them for spending their own money)-a decision it eventually had to withdraw-banks should use behavioral finance and psychology considerations also. 

Mobile banking on the other hand, is a different ball game. While the initial business models were focusing on the potential float income, the RBI put an end to that by mandating that the float balances would be held with a bank(not with the operator). However, the real goldmine is in the use of mobile banking to recharge prepaid accounts, rather than for mshopping. Presently, around 95% of Indian subscribers are prepaid(not sure about on value basis), and they recharge their accounts largely offline with banks paying the Point of Sale shopowners around 10% of the amount as commission. Given the small ticket size(say Rs 50-100), even those with access to net banking/credit card do not prefer to recharge it online unless given additional discounts, which telcos do not in fear of a backlash from their incubent POS distributors. But now, customers can put a one time deposit of Rs 1000-2000 from net banking/credit cards, and then use that amount for recharging their prepaid mobiles and for shopping. The telecom company heavily saves on prepaid mobile recharge, and also earns the commission(akin to debit card issuer bank) on that. And unlike debit cards, there is no fear of cannibalization also. 

Both these things(debit cards and mbanking) have received heavy press coverage, but few articles I’ve seen have highlighted this point, or even the similarity between these prepaid business models, which survive on commissions rather than on float.

[The article has been written by Anandh Sundar Tripuri. He is an MBA from IIM Ahmedabad 2010-12 batch and a ranker in CA/CS/CWA exams. .]

Tags:

You might like reading:

STRATONOMICS – THE CONSULTING AND STRATEGY CONCLAVE HELD AT XIMB

Constrat, the consulting and strategy consortium of Xavier Institute of Management, Bhubaneswar (XIMB), hosted its annual conclave-‘Stratonomics’. The theme for the conclave this year was ‘Digitization of value chain and Industry 4.0’. The panel of speakers included Mr. Debashish Mahapatro, CEO, Verve Consulting and MD, Eastbrook Landholdings; Mr. A Karthik, GM (Programs), Ashok Leyland; Head-Product Management (Trucks) and Mr. Sovit […]

0 comments

The Next wave of Social Networking

Recently, we were blessed with reports stating that many Facebook users had deleted their profiles from Facebook and this phenomenon is increasing with every passing day. Fatigue and over-dependence were among the reasons cited by the ‘former’ users. Add ‘Market Stagnation’ to it. Why Social Networking is important? For End-Users: Social Networking websites are for friends and near-and-dear ones to […]

0 comments
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Follow us

©2010-2023 IdeasMakeMarket.com |Contact Us | T&C | Privacy Policy

 

CONTACT US

We're not around right now. But you can send us an email and we'll get back to you, asap.

Sending

Log in with your credentials

or    

Forgot your details?

Create Account